NYPD Mafia Crime & Food Experience

Experience an authentic NYC Mafia tour led by a retired NYPD officer. Hear firsthand accounts, visit notorious gangland locations, and taste local cuisines. Book now!

Duration: 3 hours, 30 minutes
Cancellation: 1 day learn more
Highlights
  • John’s of 12th Street - We begin in the East Village at a historic New York “red sauce joint” frequented by Lucky Luciano and many others. Multiple films have been created at the restaurant, including “Boardwalk Empire,” “Sopranos,” “Get Gotti,” and more. This is where, in 1931, Luciano created the mafia Commission. The HBO series “Boardwalk Empire” was filmed here, as well as “Sopranos,” “Get Gotti,” and the upcoming documentary “After Goodfellas,” featuring one of our tour guides. John’s of 12th was established in March 1908 by John Pucciatti, who immigrated from Umbria, Italy, to the present-day East Village, a thriving Italian American community centered around 1st Avenue. The current owner, Lowell Fein, now owns the restaurant with partners Paul Dauber and Robbie Rundbaken, continuing the namesake’s legacy. The Italian neighborhood where Pucciatti moved existed even before Little Italy. We are the only Mafia experience allowed to enter the joint.
  • East Village - The Village has been a NYC Mafia stronghold since 1900. Together, we visit key Mafia locations where all five families operated.
  • St. Mark’s-in-the-Bowery Church - Burial place of New York’s political elite and John C. Colt, brother of famed gun manufacturer Samuel Colt.
  • New York Marble Cemetery - The first public cemetery in NYC. Marble Hill has below-ground vaults demanded by NYC to protect its citizens from diseases. The site is also open to the public every first Sunday of the month.
  • East Village - This is where Cosa Nostra, “Our thing,” began.
  • Orpheum Theatre - The Orpheum Theatre, formerly Player’s Theatre, is a 299-seat off-Broadway theatre on Second Avenue near the corner of St. Marks Place in the East Village neighborhood of lower Manhattan, New York City.

There may have been a concert garden on the site as early as the 1880s, but there was a theatre there by 1904. During the heyday of Yiddish theatre in the Yiddish Theater District in Manhattan, the venue was the Player’s Theatre and was part of the “Jewish Rialto” along Second Avenue. By the 1920s, the theatre was exhibiting films but was converted back to dramatic use in 1958, with the first production, “Little Mary Sunshine,” opening in November 1959.

Significant productions include the revival and revamping of Cole Porter’s musical “Anything Goes” in 1962, “Your Own Thing” in 1968, “The Me Nobody Knows” in 1970, “The Cocktail Party” in 1980, “Key Exchange” in 1981, “Broken Toys!” in 1981, “Little Shop of Horrors” in 1982, and Sandra Bernhard’s “Without You I’m Nothing.”

  • 188 1st Ave. - Once the famous Club 188 run by Charlie “Lucky” Luciano, we talk about the Genovese crime family’s powerful influence over the nightlife scene in NYC from the 1920s through today.
  • Liz Christy Bowery Houston Community Garden - Considered the oldest community garden in New York, Liz Christy Community Garden was established in 1973. In late 1973 and early 1974, the community activist group the Green Guerillas, including an energetic member named Liz Christy, cleared the lot at the northeast corner of the Bowery and East Houston. In late April 1974, the New York City Office of Housing Preservation and Development agreed to rent the site for $1 a month to the Bowery Houston Community Farm and Garden. The land where the Liz Christy Garden now stands has seen many changes in its history.
  • Albanese Meats & Poultry - The oldest butcher shop in NYC that welcomed Sicilian immigrants since the 1800s and a frequent destination for Martin Scorsese and Robert De Niro. In fact, this is where “Marty” filmed his first film.
  • St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral - The Basilica of Saint Patrick’s Old Cathedral is the original Cathedral Church of the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of New York. Since its opening over 200 years ago on the corner of Mott and Prince Streets in the Nolita section of lower Manhattan, its spiritual mission continues to be a great beacon for the Catholic Faithful and an American symbol of the triumph of religious freedom. Originally the worship center for a largely impoverished Irish community, St. Patrick’s expanded over decades to provide for the spiritual and material needs of a diverse community, including Italian, African American, Chinese, and Vietnamese Catholics. “The Godfather” was filmed inside.
  • Ravenite Social Club/Former HQ Of Gambino Crime Family - Headquarters of the Gambino crime family and John Gotti. We visit the place where the most powerful “family” operated their elusive and often deadly business. Being a local kid from Little Italy, I offer the real inside details that tour companies get wrong.
  • Chinatown - Chinese traders and sailors began trickling into the United States in the mid-eighteenth century. While this population was largely transient, small numbers stayed in New York and married. Beginning in the mid-nineteenth century, Chinese arrived in significant numbers, lured to the Pacific coast of the United States by the stories of “Gold Mountain” California during the gold rush of the 1840s and 1850s and brought by labor brokers to build the Central Pacific Railroad. Most arrived expecting to spend a few years working, thus earning enough money to return to China, build a house, and marry.

As the gold mines began yielding less and the railroad neared completion, the broad availability of cheap and willing Chinese labor in such industries as cigar-rolling and textiles became a source of tension for white laborers, who thought that the Chinese were coming to take their jobs and threaten their livelihoods. Mob violence and rampant discrimination in the west drove the Chinese east.

  • Little Italy - Little Italy is a neighborhood in New York City that began developing in the 1840s when Italian immigrants began to settle in the area. The area was first home to Dutch settlers and the Lenape tribe during the 1600s. The neighborhood was popular among immigrants because of its population of local Italian speakers and traditional Italian culture. Originally, Little Italy spanned from Lafayette Street to the Bowery and from Kenmare to Canal, but today it takes up roughly three blocks on Mulberry Street.
What's Included
  • Dinner included
  • Lunch provided
What's Not Included
  • Drinks are not included but can be purchased on the day
  • Gratuity NOT Included & Always Welcomed
Additional Information

First, let it be known that most Gangster Tours in New York City are not authentic. Our tour offers an unfiltered experience straight from the source, with no tour guide interference. Rated the #1 Thing to Do in New York, this tour is hosted by active and retired NYPD Police Officers. Hear genuine stories while visiting infamous gangland locations, walking from East Village to Little Italy. You’ll get firsthand accounts of the NYC Mafia and crimes in NYC, and enjoy local cuisines. Visit Crime Family member hangouts where they operated their secretive “family businesses,” as seen in “Get Gotti.” See the “Ravenite Social Club” and more. The tour begins at a renowned mafia “red sauce joint” established in 1908. There are three food stops with ample food provided, equivalent to a full dinner. The experience concludes with a large cannoli from one of Little Italy’s iconic pastry spots. With over 15,000 guests hosted and 2,200 five-star ratings on Airbnb, this tour is a must-do.

Location
302 E 12th St
East 12th Street
Cancellation Policy

For a full refund, cancel at least 24 hours before the scheduled departure time.

Customer Ratings
4.8
(22 Ratings)
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
815joyp
Jun 29, 2024
True local experience! - We enjoyed the stories Dennis told so much! Really felt like we were with a mafia insider and the food was delicious! Enjoyed having headsets as it made it easy to hear as we walked. If you like the mafia take this tour!
Review provided by Tripadvisor
Bigdavohughes
Jun 8, 2024
An incredible experience - My partner and I really wanted to do this walking tour and it certainly disappoint. Dennis, the tour guide and retired NYPD officer not only worked with the NYPD but had extensive experience living in the area. Dennis was fantastic reliving stories of the past gangster history but also the latest on the mob. He also bumped into locals that obviously knew and respected him and they also imparted some stories. The food on the tour was authentic and delicious and very filling. This is an fantastic tour and well worth the effort and cost. Dennis is an incredible man and very knowledgable and approachable. Well done Dennis
Review provided by Tripadvisor
Eri_t
Apr 29, 2024
Beyond our expectations! - My boyfriend & I were gifted this experience by my sister in law. As native New Yorkers, we admit that we don’t take advantage of the history & experiences this city has to offer, as much as we’d like. I’ve been to Little Italy plenty of times for San Genaro, but never took the time to really look into the history of the neighborhood. Dennis was extremely knowledgeable & informative. His personal experience gave the tour a unique perspective. He had all the answers to questions our group had. The food along the way was delicious. From spaghetti & meatballs, to fresh homemade mozzarella, to eggplant rollatini & cannolis to perfectly conclude the tour. It was easy to follow along, as Dennis provided headphones for the group to hear him as we were walking. So much better than the conventional waiting for everyone in the group to catch up, struggling to hear the guide speak. He was very efficient & kept the tour moving along, with the occasional stops & quick fact recaps. So glad we were able to do this & can’t wait for the documentary coming out on Amazon Prime that he was a part of. (That’s how you know everything he said was legit!) Very interesting and highly entertaining. 10/10 would recommend! Thank you, Dennis!
Review provided by Viator
Rainey
Apr 23, 2024
Unique, Fun and Delicious! - What an amazing evening! Do yourself a favor and take this tour, you won’t regret it! We had a great night of delicious Italian food and great true-crime stories from a retired NYPD detective who grew up in the area. Definitely a highlight of the trip!
Review provided by Viator
Zach
Mar 26, 2024
NYPD tour - Dan was excellent! He provided a lot of knowledge around the area and was a very welcoming host. Best Italian food I’ve had in my life! Highly recommended.
Review provided by Tripadvisor
Lydiamiami
Mar 18, 2024
All about the Mafia - The tour was real good. Visited and ate at places where the Mafia once ruled. Be prepared to do a lot of walking. Lots of information learned.
Review provided by Tripadvisor
Shannap496
Mar 16, 2024
Great stories, great food, great experience - From the walking into John's on 12th where we enjoyed spaghetti with the best meatball, learned some interesting history and stories of the restaurant, had some laughs, then we moved on to Russo's, 1st time I'd ever had homemade mozzarella! Excellent! We then walked a long while but the tour was fillrd with wonderful architecture of NY. Dan told some amazing stories about the Italian mob and took us to the sites where historical mob activities occurred. I enjoyed it all. The next stop, The Original Benito One; words cannot explain how delicious the Eggplant Parmigiana was outstanding , the sauce, the sauce, the sauce was everything. Little Italy was a great experience. Very eye catching and a must see. Finally we ended our tour at LaBella Ferrara, the ladies were so welcoming and literally served our group after their shop had already closed. Talk about special treatment. The peanut butter canolli was so good and the lobster tail pastry was to die for. This tour was a long walk, be prepared, wear your best walking shoes and bring your appetite. Thank you Dan for a wonderful experience
Review provided by Tripadvisor
Carla_s
Feb 14, 2024
Exciting - Very interesting tour, very well executed, made you feel like you were living in the moment. Food provided was excellent. Well worth it.
Review provided by Viator
150lilliah
Feb 8, 2024
MAFIA in Little Italy - Johnny's is the 1st stop on the Mafia tour...Do not eat before this tour.... Johnny's we had Spaghetti & Meatball meal....then the walking begins, excellent walking tour
Review provided by Tripadvisor
Kira_m
Jan 8, 2024
This was great,... - This was great, especially for people who love movies related to crime and food! Thank you for the fun time!
Review provided by Viator
Select Date and Tickets
up to 15 guests
1
Adult
September 2024
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
Today